- Original research
- Open Access
Dopamine transporter imaging with [18F]FE-PE2I PET and [123I]FP-CIT SPECT—a clinical comparison
EJNMMI Research volume 8, Article number: 100 (2018)
Dopamine transporter (DAT) imaging may be of diagnostic value in patients with clinically suspected parkinsonian disease. The purpose of this study was to compare the diagnostic performance of DAT imaging with positron emission computed tomography (PET), using the recently developed, highly DAT-selective radiopharmaceutical [18F]FE-PE2I (FE-PE2I), to the commercially available and frequently used method with [123I]FP-CIT (FP-CIT) single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) in early-stage idiopathic parkinsonian syndrome (PS).
Twenty-two patients with a clinical de novo diagnosis of PS and 28 healthy controls (HC) participating in an on-going clinical trial of FE-PE2I were analyzed in this study. Within the trial protocol, participants are clinically reassessed 2 years after inclusion. A commercially available software was used for automatic calculation of FP-CIT-specific uptake ratio (SUR). MRI-based volumes of interest combined with threshold PET segmentation were used for FE-PE2I binding potential relative to non-displaceable binding (BPND) quantification and specific uptake value ratios (SUVR).
PET with FE-PE2I revealed significant differences between patients with a clinical de novo diagnosis of PS and healthy controls in striatal DAT availability (p < 0.001), with excellent accuracy of predicting dopaminergic deficit in early-stage PS. The effect sizes were calculated for FE-PE2I BPND (Glass’s Δ = 2.95), FE-PE2I SUVR (Glass’s Δ = 2.57), and FP-CIT SUR (Glass’s Δ = 2.29). The intraclass correlation (ICC) between FE-PE2I BPND FP-CIT SUR was high in the caudate (ICC = 0.923), putamen (ICC = 0.922), and striatum (ICC = 0.946), p < 0.001. Five of the 22 patients displayed preserved striatal DAT availability in the striatum with both methods. At follow-up, a non-PS clinical diagnosis was confirmed in three of these, while one was clinically diagnosed with corticobasal syndrome. In these patients, FE-PE2I binding was also normal in the substantia nigra (SN), while significantly reduced in the remaining patients. FE-PE2I measurement of the mean DAT availability in the putamen was strongly correlated with BPND in the SN (R = 0.816, p < 0.001). Olfaction and mean putamen DAT availability was correlated using both FE-PE2I BPND and FP-CIT SUR (R ≥ 0.616, p < 0.001).
DAT imaging with FE-PE2I PET yields excellent basic diagnostic differentiation in early-stage PS, at least as good as FP-CIT SPECT.
Dopamine transporter (DAT) imaging is a key supporting diagnostic examination to distinguish patients with idiopathic parkinsonism (PS) (e.g., Parkinson’s disease, multisystem atrophy, progressive supranuclear palsy, and Lewy body dementia) from patients with Parkinson-like symptoms with preserved dopaminergic function. DAT imaging with the commercially available radiopharmaceutical [123I]FP-CIT ([123I]-ioflupane, DaTSCAN™, GE Healthcare, B.V Eindhoven, NL) SPECT (FP-CIT) is an established method, widely used in both clinical practice and research projects . In recent years, a novel radiopharmaceutical for DAT imaging, [18F]FE-PE2I ([18F]-(E)-N-(3-iodoprop-2-enyl)-2β-carbofluoroethoxy-3β-(4′-methyl-phenyl) nortropane) for PET (FE-PE2I), has emerged as a promising alternative, allowing a more selective and detailed DAT visualization and quantification [2, 3]. PET imaging with FE-PE2I permits faster patient throughput due to faster kinetics, allowing for reduced time between injection and imaging, and a shorter static imaging protocol [2, 4]. There is no need for pre- and post-scan administration of thyroid protecting agents when using [18F], and the effective dose is comparable to FP-CIT . Moreover, the spatial and temporal resolution in PET is superior compared to SPECT, and in contrast to conventional DAT SPECT imaging, in vivo visualization and quantification of DAT in extra-striatal regions, such as the substantia nigra (SN) [6, 7], is feasible with FE-PE2I. This is due to the high affinity (KD = 12 nM)  and superior selectivity for DAT over the serotonin transporter (SERT), a ratio which is found to be 29.4 for PE2I  and 2.78 for FP-CIT . The binding of FP-CIT in the midbrain is to the serotonin transporter, not to the dopamine transporter, whereas FE-PE2I is indeed selective for the DAT. The quantification of the DAT binding in the substantia nigra indicates the availability of the DAT on the cell bodies of the dopaminergic neurons. Therefore, FE-PE2I is a potentially attractive, high-quality PET imaging alternative tool for visualization of presynaptic dopamine integrity both in the striatum and in the SN in research and clinical practice. Despite the potential advantages of FE-PE2I compared to FP-CIT, these two ligands have previously not been directly compared in patients. The aim of this study was to compare the basic diagnostic performance of FE-PE2I and FP-CIT in patients with newly onset parkinsonism, fulfilling the step 1 clinical criteria for an idiopathic parkinsonian syndrome at first visit, and healthy control subjects (HC). In clinical practice, the visual interpretation of DAT imaging is very important; however, quantitative measurements are often also used, whereas in research settings the quantitative assessment is essential. Here, the primary objective was to measure the effect size and accuracy of these two DAT imaging methods in separating early-stage PS patients from control subjects, using clinically relevant quantitative image evaluation methods. The secondary objectives were to measure the intraclass correlation coefficient between FE-PE2I and FP-CIT outcome measures, to measure the correlation between DAT availability and clinical measures in PS patients, and to examine the usefulness of the quantification of DAT availability in the SN.
Patients and healthy participants
Patients within the age range of 45–80 years with newly onset clinical symptoms of suspected PS, who were referred for a first-visit specialist evaluation at the neurological department at Umeå University Hospital, were eligible for participating in the research project, which is an on-going non-profit clinical trial of FE-PE2I. The inclusion period was between November 2015 and May 2018. Patients were included if not previously diagnosed with a neurological, neurodegenerative, neurovascular, or psychiatric disorder and if fulfilling the UK Parkinson’s Disease Society Brain Bank (UKPDBB) step 1 clinical diagnostic criteria for a parkinsonian syndrome . Exclusion criteria were also severe physical illness, claustrophobia, or other contraindications against MRI, pregnancy, or nursing.
A reference group of 30 HC was recruited by advertisements in the local newspaper. Men and women within the age range of 60–80 years were eligible if in general good health and without any of the exclusion criteria listed for the patients. All healthy volunteers were investigated with the same protocol as the patients. A protocol-based clinical follow-up 2 years after inclusion for diagnostic re-evaluation is scheduled for all participants.
Sixteen of the HC in this study have been clinically confirmed still healthy at the clinical follow-up visit; however, only eight patients have been clinically reassessed up to now. Of these, one patient fulfil the clinical criteria for corticobasal syndrome (CBS), four patients have Parkinson’s disease (PD), and three patients do not fulfil the criteria for any of the neurodegenerative parkinsonian syndromes, but have been diagnosed with essential tremor, vascular parkinsonism, and undetermined tremor, respectively.
The multi-modal methodology for PET image analysis used in this study failed in two HC, and they were consequently excluded from analysis in this particular study.
The study group in this paper comprises the first included 22 patients (10 women and 12 men), mean age 68.8 ± 8.0 years, and 28 HC (13 women and 15 men), mean age 70.1 ± 4.6 years. The basic clinical features of the patients and HC in the study are presented in Table 1.
Clinical evaluation and imaging protocol
Patients and HC were evaluated clinically by a neurologist with special interest in movement disorders (JL, SaB, LE, and DB) and by a research nurse specialized in movement disorders. Clinical testing included motor function evaluation according to the third section in the Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS-III) and Hoehn and Yahr disease severity score (H&Y). Olfactory function was assessed with the Brief Smell Identification Test™ (B-SIT, Sensonics International).
After inclusion and clinical evaluation, patients and HC were examined with FP-CIT and a dynamic FE-PE2I separated by 5–21 days. For the patients, the clinical diagnosis at baseline was made before imaging and hence unbiased by the results of any imaging modality, and DAT imaging was always done before commencement of any medical treatment. The follow-up clinical diagnosis was based on established clinical criteria, in off medicated state.
FE-PE2I was synthesized on-site at Umeå University Hospital as previously described . PET/CT imaging was performed with a Discovery 690 PET/CT (GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, WI).
Following a low-dose CT (120 kV, 10 mA, 0.8-s rotation), a 75-min dynamic PET acquisition (9 × 20 s, 3 × 60 s, 5 × 180 s, 9 × 360 s) commenced at bolus intravenous injection of FE-PE2I. Target dose was 2.86 MBq/kg, limited to 200 MBq above 70 kg (Table 1). PET images were reconstructed with the SharpIR iterative algorithm (6 iterations, 24 subsets, 3.0 mm post-filter) employing time-of-flight, decay, attenuation, and scatter correction [12, 13]. The full width at half maximum resolution for this reconstruction is measured to 3.2 mm radially in the slice plane and 4.7 mm in the axial direction. An individually fitted thermoplastic mask restricted head movement. No serious adverse effects or adverse events related to FE-PE2I PET/CT imaging have occurred. Examples of a representative FE-PE2I image in one healthy subject and one PS patient participating in the study are displayed in Fig. 1. The corresponding FP-CIT images of the same individuals are also shown.
FP-CIT was purchased from GE Healthcare (B.V Eindhoven, NL). Dosage and scanning procedures of FP-CIT followed the manufacturer’s recommendations. Imaging was acquired with a hybrid all-purpose dual-head SPECT/CT scanner, the Discovery NM/CT 670 Pro (GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, WI, USA) equipped with low-energy high-resolution (LEHR) collimators. Imaging was commenced 3 h after an intravenous bolus injection of 185 MBq of the radiopharmaceutical. The SPECT projections were acquired for 30 s per projection in a 360° stepwise rotation of detectors, with a rotation radius of 15 cm. Data was collected in 128 × 128 matrices with a zoom factor of 1.5, rendering a pixel size of 2.94 × 2.94 mm. Image reconstruction was done with OSEM (8 iterations, 6 subsets) and post-filtered with a Butterworth filter (critical frequency 0.45 cm−1, order 8). The triple energy window technique  was applied for scatter correction, and data derived from an ultra-low-dose CT scan that was acquired in the same session was used for non-uniform attenuation correction. The full-width-at-half-maximum resolution for this reconstruction is measured to 12.5 mm, isotropically. The total scanning time of the protocol, including low-dose CT, is 35 min. Representative examples of FP-CIT images are shown in Fig. 1.
A 3-T MRI (Discovery MR750, GE Medical Systems Milwaukee, WI, USA) was used to acquire a high-resolution 3D fast spoiled gradient echo T1-weighted sequence (180 slices, 1 mm thickness, TR = 8.2 ms, TE = 3.2 ms, flip angle 12°, field of view 25 × 25 cm) and a susceptibility-weighted angiography (SWAN) T2*-sequence (2 mm thickness, TR-minimum = 24.3 ms, TE = 24.4 ms, flip angle 10°, field of view 22 × 22 cm).
PET image data was corrected for movement using the Linear Image Registration Tool (FLIRT) (https://fsl.fmrib.ox.ac.uk/), using the average of frames 18–20 as a reference volume. FLIRT was used for the rigid-body transformation between the PET and T1 image volumes. The average of frames 5 to 10 was used for coregistration. Freesurfer version 6.0.0 (http://surfer.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu/)  was used for automatic segmentation of the T1 images, creating caudate and putamen volumes of interest (VOIs), and the outline of the cerebellar reference region in each individual participant. The VOIs were transformed to the PET native images, where all analyses were performed.
MRI anatomical VOIs were found to be overestimated in size. To resolve this problem, PET activity values were used on the MR-based anatomical VOIs to limit the PET-active volume in a reproducible manner. VOI-based analysis was then performed to extract specific uptake value ratios (SUVR), i.e., uptake/reference ratios and non-displaceable binding (BPND) both using the entire cerebellum as reference. The average time-activity curves for patients and HC are displayed in Fig. 2. The PET quantification is schematically illustrated in Fig. 3. A more detailed description follows below.
The PET delineation algorithms, BPND calculations, and VOI analyses were coded in Matlab R2017b (Mathworks Inc., Natick, MA, USA), employing SPM 8 to read Nifti files (http://www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm/).
The VOIs were delineated according to the following steps:
The cerebellum, putamen, and caudate nucleus were automatically segmented with Freesurfer in each participant. The SN is not automatically segmented by Freesurfer. Instead, the VOIs for the right and left SN were drawn on the segmentation map in Freeview 2.0 (independently by authors SJM and SaB), guided by anatomical landmarks provided by T1-weighted transversal MRI images overlaying the SWAN images (in which the SN pars reticulata has a low signal) for better contrast. However, the exact anatomical position of the SN pars compacta, where the density of dopaminergic neurons and the DAT availability is expected to be highest, was not possible to delineate with adequate accuracy on available MRI sequences. In fact, the binding of FE-PE2I was observed to be located in the area medial to the MRI-guided VOIs, in the space between (and somewhat overlapping) the hypo-intense part of the SN and the red nucleus, and this area possibly corresponds to the location of the SN pars compacta .
PET segmentation, based on activity concentration
Due to overestimation of MR-segmented VOI volumes in the putamen and caudate nucleus, and the mismatch between the manually segmented VOI for the SN and the peak activity in the area, PET-guided automatic segmentation was performed for the putamen, caudate, and SN. The following approaches were used, which also adapted to differences in contrast and how the areas were affected by the PET resolution:
The putamen was delineated based on the PET activity within the borders of the MR-segmented VOI for the putamen by finding the 799 highest pixels (volume Vputamen = 2.5 mL).
The caudate nucleus was delineated based on the PET activity within the borders of the MR-segmented VOI for the caudate nucleus, by finding the 649 highest pixels (Vcaudate = 2.0 mL).
In order to cover the peak activity in the SN, the activity was thresholded at level Ath within a restricted search volume (x, y, z = 17, 13, 10 mm) positioned at the (mass center) midpoint of the manually MR-segmented left and right SN, respectively. The threshold level Ath was defined as:
where Amax is the highest voxel value and Aref is the reference region average value.
For the calculation of BPND on the dynamic PET data, the activity-based delineation was performed on an image summed between 27 and 75 min. For the calculations of SUVR, simulated static PET images were created by using the data collected between 51 and 75 min after injection, and the activity-based delineation was performed on these images, created to mimic a static PET scanning protocol, which could be achieved in a clinical scenario.
BP ND calculations
The BPND, defined in  of FE-PE2I, was calculated for the activity curves from the VOIs described in step (2), applying the reference Logan method without the k2 term (Eq. 7) . Using the variant without the k2 term was justified by sampling a few subjects, finding that the BPND values varied by less than 5% compared to Reference Logan with k2 precalculated from the simplified reference tissue model . The entire cerebellum was used as reference region.
The distribution volume ratio (DVR) was calculated by linear regression for times 27 to 75 min, where the Logan curve was visually inspected to be linear. The binding potential was calculated as BPND = DVR − 1.
Whole striatal BPND was calculated as a weighted sum of the caudate nucleus and putamen using the equation:
The SUVR for the putamen, caudate nucleus, and SN were calculated by dividing the VOI value in the respective regions by the uptake value in the cerebellum VOI. The SUVR value for whole striatum was calculated in analogy to the whole striatal BPND, as described above.
In the clinical setting, a static imaging protocol would be more feasible than a long dynamic scan; therefore, SUVR would be a suitable semi-quantitative outcome measure. A previous PET study with FE-PE2I has shown that the calculation of SUVR at the time interval around the peak equilibrium provides the best agreement with the estimation of BPND . However, during the dynamic scan, SUVR of FE-PE2I reached a plateau in the 50–75 min time interval (Fig. 4). This condition of pseudoequilibrium is achieved for FP-CIT within 3 to 6 h, which is typically the time interval at which the semi-quantitative specific uptake ratio (SUR) is measured in a static SPECT acquisition. Therefore, to obtain a semi-quantitative measure of SUVR with FE-PE2I in a comparable way as FP-CIT, a static scan within the time interval 50 to 75 min post injection was used. Static images were created by summing the dynamic scans between 51 and 75 min. VOIs were created on this summed image, as described in step (2) above.
The commercially available software DaTQUANT™ (GE Healthcare, Little Chalfont, UK), installed on a Xeleris 3.1 Workstation, was used for automatic FP-CIT semi-quantitative image analysis. After SPECT reconstruction, the transaxial slices were used as input to the software, which uses an automatic VOI-based semi-quantitative evaluation of the image data and compares it to an in-built set of FP-CIT reference data for statistical analysis. Pre-defined template VOIs are automatically positioned in the striatum, putamen, and caudate in each hemisphere, and in the occipital reference region. The program calculates the semi-quantitative SUR as the difference between the mean counts in each VOI and the mean counts in the background, divided by the mean counts in the background. Putamen/caudate ratios and left/right asymmetry are also presented if desired. The built-in normal database, providing normal age- and sex-stratified reference values, was not used in this study, since our SPECT image reconstruction protocol differed slightly from that used for the normal material of the software. Instead, the HC in the present study provide suitable reference values for the patients’ image data.
The statistical analyses were made in SPSS (IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 25.0).
The Mann-Whitney U test was used for mean differences between groups, applying the exact significance test option. Effect size (ES) calculation was based on the means and standard deviations of left-right averaged PET and SPECT data, using the formula for Glass’s Δ = (Mean1 − Mean2)/SDHC, where Mean1 = HC and Mean2 = patients and SDHC = the standard deviation of the mean in the HC group. Bivariate correlations were tested using Pearson’s correlation coefficient or Spearman’s rho with the two-tailed significance test option. Reliability analysis was done in SPSS using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) to index the reliability of DAT availability measured with SPECT and PET, reflecting both the correlation and measurement agreement between the two methods. The ICC for consistency (cICC) between the methods was calculated, using the two-way mixed-effects model. The discriminative diagnostic capacity of FE-PE2I and FP-CIT was analyzed graphically with receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curves, used as an index of diagnostic accuracy.
For simplicity, left and right striatal compartments were averaged for plots and statistical analysis where applicable. In patients with lateralized symptoms according to the UPDRS-III and clinical examination, the putamen and caudate contralateral to the most affected body half was identified; the hemisphere with the lowest DAT availability was used if symmetrical symptoms’ distribution.
Numbers are expressed as mean ± 1SD if not stated otherwise. The level of significance was set to p < 0.05.
DAT availability in healthy controls and patients
There were no statistically significant sex or age differences in DAT availability or age in the control group. Analysis of the entire group of HC showed a significant age correlation with FP-CIT SUR, FE-PE2I BPND, and SUVR in the caudate, putamen, and whole striatum (Table 2). However, this age-related correlation was driven by the female HC, since no significant age correlation with DAT activity was evident in men. In the group of patients with pathologic DAT availability, there was also a significant correlation between age and FP-CIT SUR and between age and FE-PE2I BPND (except for the SN).
All three methods identified five patients with baseline clinical PS but normal striatal DAT activity. One of these fulfilled clinical criteria for CBS at follow-up 2 years after scanning, and three had essential tremor, vascular parkinsonism, or undetermined tremor. The fifth patient with normal DAT has not yet been clinically re-evaluated.
Both FE-PE2I and FP-CIT revealed a significant difference in DAT availability between PS and HC, and the mean averaged DAT availability in the right and left caudate, putamen, and striatum is shown in Table 3.
Effect size and receiver operating characteristics
While the effect size (ES) was high for both methods, as shown in Table 3, especially in the putamen, FE-PE2I had slightly higher ES than FP-CIT.
The ROC curve analysis, taking all the patients and HC into account for averaged left and right putamen DAT availability measured with dynamic FE-PE2I BPND without correction for age, showed an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.903 (95% CI 0.809–0.997), for static FE-PE2I SUVR AUC = 0.886 (95% CI 0.786–0.986), and for FP-CIT SUR the AUC was 0.891 (95% CI 0.786–0.994). Adjustment for age yielded similar numbers, i.e., for FE-PE2I BPND, the AUC was 0.893 (95% CI 0.787–0.998); for FE-PE2I SUVR, the AUC was 0.890 (95% CI 0.789–0.990); and for FP-CIT SUR, the AUC was 0.899 (95% CI 0.8023–0.996). Thus, both FE-PE2I and FP-CIT have excellent discriminative properties in the differentiation between patients with dopaminergic deficit and healthy controls.
The cICC was high and significant between FP-CIT SUR and static FE-PE2I SUVR (caudate cICC = 0.870, putamen cICC = 0.796, and striatum cICC = 0.849, all p < 0.001) and even higher between FP-CIT SUR and dynamic FE-PE2I BPND (caudate cICC = 0.923, putamen cICC = 0.922, and striatum cICC = 0.946, all p < 0.001). A scatterplot of the mean DAT availability in the putamen (left and right hemispheres averaged) measured with FE-PE2I versus FP-CIT SPECT in patients and healthy controls is shown in Fig. 5.
Correlation between DAT availability in the putamen and SN
In PS patients with reduced DAT in the putamen, there was a robust linear relationship between the DAT availability in the contralateral putamen and the DAT availability in the SN (average of right and left side) measured with FE-PE2I (BPND: R = 0.690, p = 0.002; SUVR: R = 0.737, p = 0.001). In these patients, a clear correlation was also seen between contralateral putamen FP-CIT SUR and mean FE-PE2I DAT availability in the SN, measured both as BPND (R = 0.632, p = 0.007) and SUVR (R = 0.562, p = 0.019). In HC, there was a weaker correlation between the average DAT availability in the putamen and SN (FE-PE2I BPND: R = 0.446, p = 0.017; FE-PE2I SUVR: R = 0.445, p = 0.018). In Fig. 6, the relationship between DAT availability in the putamen and the SN is illustrated. For simplicity, the BPND in the left and right hemispheres is averaged. This figure also shows that the patients with a normal DAT binding in the putamen also had DAT availability within normal limits in the SN. Even though the difference is statistically significant between patients and HC, there is clearly an interval, where the mean DAT activity in the SN is overlapping between groups.
Correlation with clinical parameters
Clinical symptoms were lateralized to the right body half in 12 patients and the left side in eight patients. The clinically most affected body half corresponded with the lowest DAT binding in the contralateral hemisphere in the majority of the patients with both SPECT (90% in the caudate and putamen), with dynamic PET (85% in the caudate, 95% in the putamen) and static PET images (90% in the caudate, 85% in the putamen). In the SN, the contra-laterality correspondence was 60%.
In patients, there was no statistically significant correlation between measured DAT availability (with either of the imaging methods) and the duration of symptoms; neither was there any significant correlation with parkinsonism severity according to UPDRS-III, even though there was a trend towards a negative relationship. This did not change when controlling for age or sex, nor if the five patients with normal DAT were excluded from the analysis.
Olfaction was tested in 18/22 patients and in all healthy controls. In four patients, olfaction was normal (i.e., B-SIT score > 8 points) whereof one had CBS, one vascular parkinsonism, and one undeterminable tremor; the fourth patient, with essential tremor, was not tested. One patient with normal DAT availability (not yet clinically followed up) had impaired olfaction. Olfaction was abnormal in three HC (two of which have been confirmed still healthy after 2-year follow-up), and all of these had DAT availability well within the normal range. There were significant (p < 0.001) correlations between the B-SIT score and mean FP-CIT SUR in the caudate (R = 0.589), putamen (R = 0.729), and striatum (R = 0.710) as well as between B-SIT and mean FE-PE2I in the caudate (BPND R = 0.572, SUVR R = 0.455), putamen (BPND R = 0.616, SUVR R = 0.529), striatum (BPND R = 0.654, SUVR R = 0.539), and SN (BPND R = 0.447, SUVR R = 0.403).
Imaging of DAT availability with FE-PE2I PET/CT or FP-CIT SPECT/CT show excellent accuracy in distinction between HC and patients with de novo PS in an early clinical stage. A significant difference in DAT availability was measured between HC and PS. The ES was large and clinically relevant and was slightly higher for FE-PE2I than FP-CIT.
Both FE-PE2I and FP-CIT revealed normal striatal DAT availability in five patients who fulfilled the UKPDBB criteria for PS. These patients also displayed FE-PE2I binding in the SN within the range of HC. In three of these patients, the diagnosis at follow-up was essential tremor, undetermined tremor, and vascular parkinsonism, respectively. The fourth patient was clinically diagnosed with CBS at follow-up. It is known that CBS does not always show any signs of dopaminergic deficit in an early-stage disease [20, 21], and none of the imaging methods detected any DAT reduction in this patient, who had less than 1 year of symptoms’ duration at the time of imaging. The fifth patient with normal DAT availability has not yet been reassessed clinically.
According to the study protocol, all participants (including HC) will be clinically reassessed 24 months after inclusion, and future clinical follow-up will provide more clinical information in all participants and more specific clinical diagnoses for the patients.
A slight discrepancy between FE-PE2I and FP-CIT was represented in one HC who had relatively low DAT binding with FE-PE2I especially in the caudate, but normal FP-CIT SUR. When reviewing the MRI of this individual, very small lacunar infarcts were observed in the caudate and in the putamen, which may explain the lower and somewhat irregular DAT binding in PET. The higher spatial resolution observed with FE-PE2I PET imaging may be less permissive of such irregularities compared to SPECT imaging in which the spatial resolution is inferior and partial volume effects or smoothing may “compensate” for small focal lesions. This particular HC had midbrain DAT binding in the lower range among the HC, but intact olfactory function. It is unclear what this signifies, and this emphasizes the importance of clinical follow-up in both the healthy controls and the patients in this study. Some of the PS patients with significantly low FE-PE2I BPND in the putamen had DAT availability in the SN within the range of the HC, which is yet also of uncertain clinical significance. In addition, in Fig. 6, a slight overlap of measured DAT binding in the SN can be observed between HC and patients. The clinical follow-up of those PS and HC participants will probably help understand the relevance of these findings.
The FE-PE2I binding region in the midbrain was observed medial to and overlapping the part of the SN which has a low intensity on the T1 and SWAN MRI images. The low-intensity part of SN in these MRI sequences probably represents the SN pars reticulata . However, the observed FE-PE2I binding region presumably originate from the DAT in the dopamine neuron-rich areas in the midbrain, e.g., SN pars compacta, which is a complex structure, difficult to visualize and delineate on conventional T1 and SWAN MRI sequences . Further studies will elucidate these findings in more detail.
Age dependency has been reported for both men and women previously for both FP-CIT [23,24,25,26] and FE-PE2I . In the present study, an age-related DAT decline in women but not in men was observed. This was previously reported in a different study using FP-CIT in healthy volunteers  within the same age range as that of the present study. It is interesting that the same phenomenon is observed also in the present study with both FP-CIT and FE-PE2I. Conceivably, the decline in women may possibly be accelerated in older age and therefore accentuated even in a small-sized group and constricted age range. In our study however, age differences did not have any relevant impact on the diagnostic accuracy. The lack of correlation between clinical severity, as measured with UPDRS-III, and DAT availability was also reported by Fazio et al. in a recently published study  and may be due to the early stage of disease in the patients and the small group size.
PET imaging with FE-PE2I allows for shorter interval between injection and imaging and shorter static imaging protocols (around 20 min, or less) than FP-CIT SPECT imaging (around 30 min). In particular, a short imaging protocol is an advantage for brain imaging of patients with movement disorders, since these patients often suffer from pain and stiff neck, which, apart from the disease-specific motor dysfunction, makes it difficult for many patients to lie still in prone position for longer times. In our study, the dynamic protocol is very long; however, static PET imaging may be accomplished in 20 min. In a recently published study , a static acquisition obtained in the time interval between 16.5 and 42 min, corresponding to the peak equilibrium of FE-PE2I, provided the best agreement with BPND with comparable effect size in differentiating PD patients from controls. In our study, we selected a 20-min static scan obtained at 50 min post injection, corresponding to the pseudoequilibrium of FE-PE2I, i.e., when the ratio between the target and the reference region becomes constant. This time window provided good diagnostic accuracy, with an ES between patients and HC slightly lower than the ES obtained using BPND. We did not observe any systematic difference in ES between the 50–70-min static protocol and the previously reported time window  (data not shown). The image contrast observed in static images at 50–70 min post injection seems to be sufficient for visual interpretation in a clinical setting. The time window between 50 and 70 min also offers a practical solution similar to other frequently used PET imaging protocols, e.g., [18F]FDG of [68Ga]DOTATOC.
The primary objective of this study was to compare the performance of one established DAT imaging method, FP-CIT SPECT, with PET imaging using a new and more selective DAT radiopharmaceutical, FE-PE2I, in a clinically relevant setting, in which the clinical diagnosis is still unclear. In this situation, the diagnostic work-up of suspected PS can benefit from supporting evidence of reduced dopaminergic integrity by DAT imaging. A caveat with this study, as with imaging studies in PS in general, is the lack of a golden standard diagnosis (i.e., histopathological examination at autopsy) which is seldom an opportunity. A reliable clinical diagnosis does require a relatively long follow-up. The specific clinical diagnoses of the majority of the patients in this study remains to be confirmed. However, some of the participants do have a follow-up clinical diagnosis that corresponds well with the outcome of the SPECT and PET examinations.
The accessibility and costs of SPECT radiopharmaceuticals for DAT imaging vary between countries. The similar basic diagnostic results achieved with FE-PE2I PET compared to FP-CIT SPECT suggest that FE-PE2I PET is a valuable alternative DAT imaging method in cases of limited supply of DAT-SPECT radiopharmaceuticals. In the clinical setting, FE-PE2I PET has several advantages over FP-CIT SPECT: (i) superior DAT selectivity, (ii) shorter static imaging protocols without the need for pharmacological thyroid protection, (iii) better image resolution with PET, and (iv) possibility to obtain quantitative outcome measures with full dynamic PET acquisitions, when required. Additional studies across different centers are needed to further evaluate the advantages and other potential applications of FE-PE2I PET.
This study confirms that DAT imaging with FE-PE2I PET exhibits excellent differentiation between subjects with and without dopaminergic deficit, offering a valuable supporting diagnostic tool for the evaluation of patients with newly onset clinical parkinsonism. FE-PE2I PET displays a high diagnostic correspondence with established imaging with FP-CIT SPECT, and either method may therefore be used with diagnostic confidence in the clinic. Further studies are warranted to assess the potential additional diagnostic information of imaging the DAT in the midbrain using FE-PE2I.
- BPND :
Binding potential relative to non-displaceable binding
Brief Smell Identification Test™ (Sensonics International)
[18F]FE-PE2I, [18F]-(E)-N-(3-iodoprop-2-enyl)-2β-carbofluoroethoxy-3β-(4′-methyl-phenyl) nortropane
[123I]FP-CIT, [123I]-ioflupane, DaTSCAN™ (GE Healthcare, B.V Eindhoven, NL)
Hoehn and Yahr disease severity score
Healthy control subjects
Low-energy high resolution
Magnetic resonance imaging
Ordered subset expectation maximization
Positron emission tomography
Single-photon emission computed tomography
Specific uptake ratio
Specific uptake value ratio
United Kingdom’s Parkinson’s Disease Society Brain Bank
Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale, motor part
Volume of interest
Darcourt J, Booij J, Tatsch K, Varrone A, Vander Borght T, Kapucu OL, et al. EANM procedure guidelines for brain neurotransmission SPECT using 123I-labelled dopamine transporter ligands, version 2. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging. 2010;37:443–50.
Fazio P, Svenningsson P, Forsberg A, Jonsson EG, Amini N, Nakao R, et al. Quantitative analysis of 18F-(E)-N-(3-iodoprop-2-enyl)-2 -carbofluoroethoxy-3-(4′-methyl-phenyl) nortropane binding to the dopamine transporter in Parkinson disease. J Nucl Med. 2015;56:714–20.
Fazio P, Svenningsson P, Cselényi Z, Halldin C, Farde L, Varrone A. Nigrostriatal dopamine transporter availability in early Parkinson’s disease. Mov Disord. 2018;33:592–9.
Sonni I, Fazio P, Schain M, Halldin C, Svenningsson P, Farde L, et al. Optimal acquisition time window and simplified quantification of dopamine transporter availability using 18F-FE-PE2I in healthy controls and Parkinson’s disease patients. J Nucl Med. 2016;57:1529–34.
Lizana H, Johansson L, Axelsson JE, Larsson Strömvall A, Ögren M, Linder J, et al. Whole-body biodistribution and dosimetry of the dopamine transporter radioligand 18F-FE-PE2I in human subjects. J Nucl Med. 2018; (e-pub ahead of print).
Varrone A, Tóth M, Steiger C, Takano A, Guilloteau D, Ichise M, et al. Kinetic analysis and quantification of the dopamine transporter in the nonhuman primate brain with 11C-PE2I and 18F-FE-PE2I. J Nucl Med. 2011;52:132–9.
Sasaki T, Ito H, Kimura Y, Arakawa R, Takano H, Seki C, et al. Quantification of dopamine transporter in human brain using PET with 18F-FE-PE2I. J Nucl Med. 2012;53:1065–73.
Varrone A, Steiger C, Schou M, Takano A, Finnema SJ, Guilloteau D, et al. In vitro autoradiography and in vivo evaluation in cynomolgus monkey of [18F]FE-PE2I, a new dopamine transporter PET radioligand. Synapse. 2009;63:871–80.
Emond P, Garreau L, Chalon S, Boazi M, Caillet M, Bricard J, et al. Synthesis and ligand binding of nortropane derivatives: N-substituted 2beta-carbomethoxy-3beta-(4′-iodophenyl)nortropane and N-(3-iodoprop-(2E)-enyl)-2beta-carbomethoxy-3beta-(3′,4′-disubstituted phenyl)nortropane. New high-affinity and selective compound. J Med Chem. 1997;40(9):1366–72.
Abi-Dargham A, Gandelman MS, DeErausquin GA, Zea-Ponce Y, Zoghbi SS, Baldwin RM, et al. SPECT imaging of dopamine transporters in human brain with iodine-123-fluoroalkyl analogs of beta-CIT. J Nucl Med. 1996;37(7):1129–33.
Gibb WR, Lees AJ. The significance of the Lewy body in the diagnosis of idiopathic Parkinson’s disease. Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol. 1989;15:27–44.
Bettinardi V, Presotto L, Rapisarda E, Picchio M, Gianolli L, Gilardi MC. Physical performance of the new hybrid PET∕CT Discovery-690. Med Phys. 2011;38:5394–411.
Wallstén E, Axelsson J, Sundström T, Riklund K, Larsson A. Subcentimeter tumor lesion delineation for high-resolution 18F-FDG PET images: optimizing correction for partial-volume effects. J Nucl Med Technol. 2013;41:85–91.
Ogawa K, Harata Y, Ichihara T, Kubo A, Hashimoto S. A practical method for position-dependent Compton-scatter correction in single photon emission CT. IEEE Trans Med Imaging. 1991;10:408–12.
Fischl B, Salat DH, Busa E, Albert M, Dieterich M, Haselgrove C, et al. Whole brain segmentation: automated labeling of neuroanatomical structures in the human brain. Neuron. 2002;33:341–55.
Lehéricy S, Bardinet E, Poupon C, Vidailhet M, François C. 7 tesla magnetic resonance imaging: a closer look at substantia nigra anatomy in Parkinson’s disease. Mov Disord. 2014;29(13):1574–81.
Innis RB, Cunningham VJ, Delforge J, Fujita M, Gjedde A, Gunn RN, et al. Consensus nomenclature for in vivo imaging of reversibly binding radioligands. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab. 2007;27:1533–9.
Logan J, Fowler JS, Volkow ND, Wang G-J, Ding Y-S, Alexoff DL. Distribution volume ratios without blood sampling from graphical analysis of PET data. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab. 1996;16:834–40.
Lammertsma AA, Hume SP. Simplified reference tissue model for PET receptor studies. NeuroImage. 1996;4(3):153–8.
Hammesfahr S, Antke C, Mamlins E, Beu M, Wojtecki L, Ferrea S, et al. FP-CIT- and IBZM-SPECT in corticobasal syndrome: results from a clinical follow-up study. Neurodegener Dis. 2016;16(5–6):342–7.
Ceravolo R, Rossi C, Cilia R, Tognoni G, Antonini A, Volterrani D, et al. Evidence of delayed nigrostriatal dysfunction in corticobasal syndrome: a SPECT follow-up study. Parkinsonism Relat Disord. 2013;19(5):557–9.
Massey LA, Yousry TA. Anatomy of the substantia nigra and subthalamic nucleus on MR imaging. Neuroimaging Clin N Am. 2010;20(1):7–27.
Jakobson Mo S, Larsson A, Linder J, Birgander R, Edenbrandt L, Stenlund H, et al. 123I-FP-Cit and 123I-IBZM SPECT uptake in a prospective normal material analysed with two different semiquantitative image evaluation tools. Nucl Med Commun. 2013;34(10):978–89.
Yamamoto H, Arimura S, Nakanishi A, Shimo Y, Motoi Y, Ishiguro K, et al. Age-related effects and gender differences in Japanese healthy controls for [123I] FP-CIT SPECT. Ann Nucl Med. 2017;31:407–12.
Varrone A, Dickson JC, Tossici-Bolt L, Sera T, Asenbaum S, Booij J, et al. European multicentre database of healthy controls for [123I]FP-CIT SPECT (ENC-DAT): age-related effects, gender differences and evaluation of different methods of analysis. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging. 2013;40:213–27.
Matsuda H, Murata M, Mukai Y, Sako K, Ono H, Toyama H, et al. Japanese multicenter database of healthy controls for [123I]FP-CIT SPECT. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging. 2018;45(8):1405–16.
Shingai Y, Tateno A, Arakawa R, Sakayori T, Kim W, Suzuki H, et al. Age-related decline in dopamine transporter in human brain using PET with a new radioligand [18F]FE-PE2I. Ann Nucl Med. 2014;28:220–6.
We thank the patients and healthy volunteers for participating in this study and the research nurses Mona Edström and Kajsa-Lotta Burström and the staff at the Departments of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine at the University Hospital of Umeå for their excellent work. We also thank Simon Vallin, statistician at the Register Center North, Västerbotten County Council, for the statistical support.
This study was supported by grants from the Swedish Parkinson’s Disease Foundation and The Västerbotten County Council, Sweden.
Availability of data and materials
Data supporting the findings of this study are available within the article and its supplementary information files. Collected raw data and derived data from this on-going clinical trial are currently available only to the collaborating scientists and are not publicly available due to relevant data protection laws.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study was approved by the regional Ethics Committee of Umeå University (registration numbers dnr 2014-364-31, 2015-394-32, 2016-300-32, and 2017-369-32) and the local radiation safety committee at the University Hospital of Umeå (registration numbers 1417, 1616, and 1717) and conducted within a registered on-going, non-profit phase II clinical trial of [18F]FE-PE2I (Eudra CT no. 2015–003045-26, the PEARL-PD project) approved by the Swedish Medical Products Agency (registration numbers 5.1-2015-76714, 5.1-2016-64141, and 5.12017-76924).
Consent for publication
All procedures performed in in this study were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards. Oral and written informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Jakobson Mo, S., Axelsson, J., Jonasson, L. et al. Dopamine transporter imaging with [18F]FE-PE2I PET and [123I]FP-CIT SPECT—a clinical comparison. EJNMMI Res 8, 100 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13550-018-0450-0
- Parkinson’s disease
- Dopamine transporter (DAT)