- Original research
- Open Access
Phantom and clinical evaluation of the effect of full Monte Carlo collimator modelling in post-SIRT yttrium-90 Bremsstrahlung SPECT imaging
© The Author(s). 2018
- Received: 23 October 2017
- Accepted: 10 January 2018
- Published: 22 January 2018
Post-therapy SPECT/CT imaging of 90Y microspheres delivered to hepatic malignancies is difficult, owing to the continuous, high-energy Bremsstrahlung spectrum emitted by 90Y. This study aimed to evaluate the utility of a commercially available software package (HybridRecon, Hermes Medical Solutions AB) which incorporates full Monte Carlo collimator modelling. Analysis of image quality was performed on both phantom and clinical images in order to ultimately provide a recommendation of an optimum reconstruction for post-therapy 90Y microsphere SPECT/CT imaging.
A 3D-printed anthropomorphic liver phantom was filled with 90Y with a sphere-to-background ratio of 4:1 and imaged on a GE Discovery 670 SPECT/CT camera. Datasets were reconstructed using ordered-subsets expectation maximization (OSEM) 1–7 iterations in order to identify the optimal OSEM reconstruction (5 iterations, 15 subsets). Quantitative analysis was subsequently carried out on phantom datasets obtained using four reconstruction algorithms: the default OSEM protocol (2 iterations, 10 subsets) and the optimised OSEM protocol, both with and without full Monte Carlo collimator modelling. The quantitative metrics contrast recovery (CR) and background variability (BV) were calculated.
The four algorithms were then used to retrospectively reconstruct 10 selective internal radiation therapy (SIRT) patient datasets which were subsequently blind scored for image quality by a consultant radiologist.
The optimised OSEM reconstruction (5 iterations, 15 subsets with full MC collimator modelling) increased the CR by 42% (p < 0.001) compared to the default OSEM protocol (2 iterations, 10 subsets). The use of full Monte Carlo collimator modelling was shown to further improve CR by 14% (30 mm sphere, CR = 90%, p < 0.05).
The consultant radiologist had a significant preference for the optimised OSEM over the default OSEM protocol (p < 0.001), with the optimised OSEM being the favoured reconstruction in every one of the 10 clinical cases presented.
OSEM (5 iterations, 15 subsets) with full Monte Carlo collimator modelling is quantitatively the optimal image reconstruction for post-SIRT 90Y Bremsstrahlung SPECT/CT imaging. The use of full Monte Carlo collimator modelling for correction of image-degrading effects significantly increases contrast recovery without degrading clinical image quality.
- Quantitative SPECT
- Yttrium-90 Bremsstrahlung
- Image reconstruction
- Monte Carlo scatter correction
Selective internal radiation therapy (SIRT) of hepatic malignancies involves delivery of 90Y microspheres to tumour via hepatic arteries . Prior to administration of the 90Y microspheres, it is recommended that a 99mTc MAA scan is performed to evaluate the shunting of activity to the lungs  but there is a debate about whether the MAA distribution reflects that of the therapeutic 90Y [2–4]. A post-therapy Bremsstrahlung scan was recommended in the 2007 report from the Radioembolization Brachytherapy Oncology Consortium , but more recent studies have demonstrated that PET may provide better quantification of 90Y distribution [5, 6]. As gamma cameras are cheaper and more numerous than PET scanners , their use for post-therapy imaging of 90Y SIRT is expected to continue. The improvement of 90Y Bremsstrahlung imaging will hence be beneficial to both current and future clinical needs.
Difficulties in imaging 90Y using SPECT arise from its continuous Bremsstrahlung spectrum with energies up to 2.3 MeV, meaning that traditional energy-based scatter rejection methods are ineffective . The presence of scattered photons in SPECT images leads to degradations in contrast and thus in quantification .
Early methods of scatter reduction included the dual or triple energy window [9, 10] techniques. More modern, computationally heavy methods use Monte Carlo algorithms to model scatter in the object [11, 12] and, more recently, in the collimator and detector [13, 14].
Monte Carlo algorithms which model the scatter in the object are effective for radionuclides which have a single low-energy photopeak (e.g., 99mTc) , when the detector response is assumed to be Gaussian , but for higher energy isotopes which do not have one single photopeak (e.g., 90Y), they are not effective. The full Monte Carlo (MC) collimator simulation in HybridRecon (HERMES Medical Solutions AB, Stockholm, Sweden) incorporates all photon interactions at the collimator, including both primary and scattered photons, in addition to considering scatter within the object. This is necessary owing to the increased amount of septal penetration, scatter within the collimator itself, and lead X-ray fluorescence with a higher energy radionuclide .
HybridRecon uses a scatter modelling method known as convolution-based forced detection . The software uses pre-calculated probability density functions of the 90Y spectrum, which were generated using PENELOPE MC code , carries out the simulation according to Rault et al. , and utilises a β particle spectrum adopted from the Brookhaven National Laboratory database . During the reconstruction, the photon energy is sampled from the Bremsstrahlung probability density function and the photon path at the object is modelled using the MC simulator. Scattered photons are forced to scatter towards the detector, producing 3D sub-projections; due to the continuous nature of the 90Y Bremsstrahlung spectrum, several sub-projections are created with different energy windows. Once the scatter sub-projections have been simulated, they are convolved to the detector plane with attenuation modelling. This convolution is carried out using pre-calculated MC depth-dependent Gaussian point spread functions which model the collimator and detector response.
The purpose of this work is firstly to optimise ordered-subsets expectation maximization (OSEM) reconstruction of 90Y SPECT and further to evaluate the effect of the advanced MC scatter correction offered by HybridRecon on image quality and quantification.
The AbdoMan™ phantom , a 3D-printed liver phantom with fillable spherical inserts, was used to perform quantitative evaluations of the reconstruction algorithms under test. The anthropomorphic nature of the AbdoMan™ phantom enabled quantitative analysis of image quality to be performed in a more clinically realistic scenario than using most commercially available phantoms.
Hot spheres of 10, 20, 30, and 40 mm diameter and a 40-mm hot sphere with a 25-mm solid (cold) centre were inserted into the warm liver background region with a sphere:background ratio of 4:1 and a clinically relevant total activity of 1340 MBq 90Y. The phantom was scanned on a GE Discovery 670 dual-headed SPECT/CT camera three times (GE Healthcare, Haifa, Israel) using the clinical protocol (energy window 50–150 keV, MEGP collimators, 128 × 128 matrix size, 360° acquisition, 90 views, 20 s/view) in order to obtain three acquisitions of the phantom.
HybridRecon (Version 1.1C, HERMES Medical Solutions AB) was used to perform all reconstructions whilst HybridViewer (Version 2.6F, HERMES Medical Solutions AB) was used to view and analyse the reconstructed images. All images were attenuation corrected using CT data and had the resolution recovery option switched on. Where full MC collimator modelling was not enabled, standard MC scatter correction was carried out.
One acquisition of the phantom was reconstructed with OSEM 1–7 iterations and 15 subsets in order to ascertain the optimum OSEM reconstruction. Previous work on optimisation of 99mTc reconstruction in SPECT imaging had shown that five iterations and 16 subsets yield the best compromise between resolution and noise  but owing to the number of projections at which data were acquired at this institution, 16 subsets were not a possible option. Instead, the nearest alternative of 15 subsets was used. The optimum number of OSEM iterations for 90Y was found via quantitative analysis as described below.
Once the optimised OSEM reconstruction had been identified, all three of the acquisitions were reconstructed with the GE default OSEM protocol (2 iterations and 10 subsets) and the optimised OSEM protocol, both with and without full MC collimator modelling.
Quantitative phantom analysis
Quantitative analysis on phantom datasets was carried out on unfiltered images. Circular regions of interest (ROIs) were drawn onto the hot spheres, on the widest slice of the sphere. ROIs of diameters equal to those of the hot spheres were drawn in the background region, positioned concentrically on three slices: one near the top, the bottom, and the middle of the phantom. The regions were drawn onto transaxial slices of the CT image and copied across to the aligned SPECT images.
Contrast recovery (CR) and background variability (BV) were both calculated as in the NEMA standard . Data were exported into Microsoft Excel (2010) for analysis, with statistical analysis being carried out using IBM SPSS Statistics (Version 22.0, 2013).
Having optimised the reconstructions using phantom datasets, the raw datasets of 10 consecutive patients (administered activity range = 860–2370 MBq; mean = 1570 MBq) who had undergone SIRT therapy for metastatic colorectal cancer were retrospectively reconstructed, a practice which does not require informed consent at this institution. As with the phantom datasets, each patient dataset was reconstructed using four different methods: the default OSEM protocol and the optimised OSEM protocol, both with and without full MC collimator modelling. For the clinical evaluation, a 0.4-cm−1 Butterworth filter was applied to the images using HybridRecon.
Criteria against which the consultant radiologist was asked to score the patient reconstructions
Overall image quality
1, poor—5, excellent
1, poor—5, excellent
Visibility of necrotic regions
1, poor—5, excellent
Liver background noise
1, unacceptable—5, minimal
Since the CR of the 10- and 20-mm spheres were so low owing to the partial volume effect, they were considered to be of limited use for optimisation and were thus excluded from the analysis.
Considering the results obtained in this analysis, it was decided that the optimised OSEM reconstruction for 90Y was 5 iterations and 15 subsets.
Though it seems that there is an increase in BV associated with the use of full MC collimator modelling, this difference is not statistically significant owing to the large variability in the values.
Quantitatively, it was concluded that the optimised OSEM reconstruction with full MC collimator modelling was the best reconstruction owing to the significant increases in CR observed. The clinical evaluation was then used to confirm whether the image quality of this reconstruction was also superior or whether the increase in background variability had led to a deterioration in image quality.
Results from clinical evaluation of patient images. Numbers are mean averages over all 10 patients and numbers in brackets indicate the standard deviation
Overall image Quality
Visibility of necrotic regions (where applicable)
Liver background Noise level
In every one of the 10 cases, the optimised OSEM reconstruction scored higher than the default OSEM reconstruction. Although the noise levels in the optimised OSEM images were higher, they were still considered to be acceptable by the radiologist and the increased contrast levels in the optimised OSEM resulted in it being scored more highly than the default reconstruction.
A Wilcoxon signed-ranks test was performed to test whether there was a statistically significant difference in each of the metrics described in Table 1 when full MC collimator modelling was used, compared to when it was not. The test revealed no significant differences for any of the metrics.
The aim of this investigation into post-SIRT 90Y SPECT imaging was to optimise OSEM reconstruction and to assess whether full MC collimator modelling could be used to improve image quality and quantification. Based on these results, a recommendation of a single optimal reconstruction would be made.
The optimised OSEM protocol with full MC collimator modelling (5 iterations, 15 subsets) yielded a higher CR than the default OSEM protocol (2 iterations, 10 subsets), with an increase of over 42% (p < 0.001) observed for the 30 mm sphere. Even without the full MC collimator modelling, the optimised OSEM still demonstrated a great advantage in CR over the default protocol, with a 28% increase observed for the same sphere (p < 0.01). As well as performing best in the phantom optimisation, optimised OSEM also scored higher than the default OSEM protocol for all of the 10 patient datasets presented to the radiologist.
For both the optimised and default OSEM, the use of MC collimator modelling increased the CR values and, in a number of cases, this difference was significant (e.g., optimised OSEM CR increase = 14%, p = 0.048, 30-mm sphere). A previous study using the “Utrecht Monte Carlo System” has shown, using one acquisition of the NEMA IQ phantom, that Monte Carlo-based scatter correction for 90Y yielded a CR of 88% for a 37-mm sphere . This study, using commercially available software, demonstrated a CR of 90% for a 30-mm sphere. A major limitation of 90Y SPECT imaging is the difficulty in applying traditional scatter correction techniques , which model the scatter within the object, owing to the continuous nature of the Bremsstrahlung spectrum and absence of a photopeak . It is therefore not surprising that HybridRecon, which additionally models scatter within the detector and collimator, improves quantification of 90Y images.
It was found that BV does not differ significantly when MC collimator modelling is applied. Though from Fig. 3b it would appear that the BV does increase, the variability of the BV values between different acquisitions is so great that this increase is likely to be of no consequence (and it is not significant, p > 0.05), as confirmed by the results of the clinical study.
Both the phantom and patient dataset optimisation revealed the optimised OSEM reconstructions to be preferable to the default OSEM reconstructions. Having demonstrated that full MC collimator modelling improves CR, and thus quantification, without altering clinical image quality, it is therefore recommended that SPECT images of post-SIRT 90Y are reconstructed with this algorithm. For presentation to the radiologist for reporting, consideration should be given to applying a post-filter, but no post-filter should be applied when using the image for quantification purposes.
OSEM with five iterations and 15 subsets produces significantly improved 90Y SPECT/CT images compared with the default protocol (2 iterations and 10 subsets). Use of full MC collimator modelling significantly improves CR, whilst not degrading image quality, making it suitable for aiding future quantification. Therefore, OSEM with five iterations and 15 subsets, incorporating full MC collimator modelling if available, is the recommended reconstruction algorithm for post-SIRT 90Y SPECT/CT imaging.
We thank Michael Tapner (Sirtex Technology Pty Ltd) for providing the 90Y activity. We thank Antti Sohlberg and Helena McMeekin (HERMES Medical Solutions AB) for their support regarding the HybridRecon software. We thank the Joint Department of Physics at the Royal Marsden Hospital and the Institute of Cancer Research for the loan of the AbdoMan™ phantom.
This research project was not funded. DM is funded by a National Institute for Health Research/Health Education England Clinical Lectureship (ICA-CL-2016-02-009). The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NHS, the National Institute for Health Research, the Health Education England, or the Department of Health.
CAP contributed to the study design and data acquisition; performed the data processing, analysis, and interpretation; and drafted the manuscript. KMB scored the clinical images and contributed to the data interpretation and manuscript revision. ETH contributed to the data processing and manuscript revision. MDW contributed to the data acquisition and manuscript revision. DRM contributed to the study design and data acquisition, data interpretation, and manuscript revision. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Patient data was used in this project in the form of retrospectively reconstructed image datasets. This practice does not require informed consent at Oxford University Hospitals nor was specific ethics approval required.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
- Kennedy A, Nag S, Salem R, Murthy R, AJ ME, Nutting C, et al. Recommendations for radioembolization of hepatic malignancies using yttrium-90 microsphere brachytherapy: a consensus panel report from the radioembolization brachytherapy oncology consortium. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2007;68(1):13.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rong X, Du Y, Ljungberg M, Rault E, Vandenberghe S, Frey EC. Development and evaluation of an improved quantitative 90Y bremsstahlung SPECT method. Med Phys. 2012;39(5):2346.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Ulrich G, Dudeck O, Furth C, Ruf J, Grosser OS, Adolf D, et al. Predictive value of intratumoral 99mTc-macroaffregated albumin uptake in patients with colorectal liver metastases scheduled for radioembolization with 90Y-microspheres. J Nucl Med. 2013;54(4):516.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kao YH, Tan AEH, Burgmans MC, Irani FG, Khoo LS, Lo RHG, et al. Image-guided personalized predictive dosimetry by artery-specific SPECT/CT partition modelling for safe and effective 90Y radioembolization. J Nucl Med. 2012;53(4):559.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Elschot M, Vermolen BJ, Lam MGEH, de Keizer B, van den Bosch MAAJ, de Jong HWAM. Quantitative comparison of PET and Bremsstrahlung SPECT for imaging the in vivo yttrium-90 microsphere distribution after liver radioembolization. PLoS One. 2013;8(2):e55742.Google Scholar
- Rowley LM, Bradley KM, Boardman P, Hallam A, McGowan DR. Optimization of image reconstruction for yttrium-90 SIRT on a LYSO PET/CT system using a Bayesian penalized likelihood reconstruction algorithm. J Nuc Med. 2017;58(4):658–64.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kangasmaa TS, Constable C, Hippeläinen E, Sohlberg AO. Multicenter evaluation of single-photon emission computed tomography quantification with third-party reconstruction software. Nuc Med Comms. 2016;37(9):983–7.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bailey DL, Willowson KP. Quantitative SPECT/CT: SPECT joins PET as a quantitative imaging modality. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging. 2014;41(Suppl 1):S17.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jaszczak RJ, Greer KL, Floyd CE, Harris CG, Coleman RE. Improved SPECT quantification using compensation for scattered photons. J Nucl Med. 1984;25(8):893.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ichihara T, Ogawa K, Motomura N, Kubo A, Hashimoto S. Compton scatter compensation using triple-energy window method for single- and dual-isotope SPECT. J Nucl Med. 1993;34(12):2216.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sohlberg A, Watabe H, Iida H. Acceleration of Monte Carlo-based scatter compensation for cardiac SPECT. Phys Med Biol. 2008;53(14):N277.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kangasmaa TS, Kuikka JT, Vanninen EJ, Mussalo HM, Laitinen TP, Sohlberg AO. Half-time myocardial perfusion SPECT imaging with attenuation and Monte Carlo-based scatter correction. Nucl Med Commun. 2011;32(11):1040.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sohlberg AO, Kajaste MT. Fast Monte Carlo-simulator with full collimator and detector response modelling for SPECT. Ann Nucl Med. 2012;26(1):92.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Elschot M, Lam MGEH, van den Bosch MAAJ, Viergever MA, de Jong HWAM. Quantitative Monte Carlo-based 90Y SPECT reconstruction. J Nucl Med. 2013;54(9):1557–63.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- de Jong H, Slijpen E, Beekman F. Acceleration of Monte Carlo SPECT simulation using convolution based forced detection. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci. 2001;48:58–64.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Baró J, Sempau J, Fernández-Varea JM, Salvat F. PENELOPE: an algorithm for Monte Carlo simulation of the penetration and energy loss of electrons and positrons in matter. Nucl Instrum Methods Phys Res, Sect B. 1995;100:31–46.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Rault E, Staelens S, Van Holen R, De Beenhouwer J, Vandenberghe S. Fast simulation of yttrium-90 Bremsstrahlung photons with GATE; 2012. p. 2943.Google Scholar
- Stabin MG, da Luz LC. Decay data for internal and external dose assessment. Health Phys. 2002;83:471–5.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Gear JI, Cummings C, Craig AJ, Divoli A, CDC L, Tapner M, et al. Abdo-Man: a 3D-printed anthropomorphic phantom for validating quantitative SIRT. EJNMMI Physics. 2016;3(17). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40658-016-0151-6.
- Kangasmaa T, Sohlberg A, Kuikka JT. Reduction of collimator correction artefacts with bayesian reconstruction in SPECT. Int J Mol Imaging. 2011;2011:630813. 6 pagesView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- National Electrical Manufacturers Association. NEMA standards publication NU 2–2007: performance measurements of positron emission tomographs. 2007.Google Scholar